Tuesday, November 17, 2026 Ink-stained bodybuilding news since 2026 Get the Pump Report →
History

Nick Walker Picks Flex Wheeler as Best Bodybuilder Never to Win the Olympia

In a viral winner-stays-on challenge, the reigning Mr. Olympia chose Flex Wheeler over Kai Greene, Victor Martinez and more.

Kai Greene's run through the bracket was the surprise; Flex's finish was the headline.

Walker's Pick: Flex Wheeler

What happens when you ask the reigning Mr. Olympia to rank the best bodybuilders who never won the Olympia? You get a surprisingly decisive answer. Nick Walker played a "winner stays on" challenge on Instagram, and the last man standing was Flex Wheeler.

How the challenge worked

The rules were simple: compare two athletes at their absolute best, pick the better physique, and the winner faces the next challenger. The field was stacked with legends who never took the Sandow: Lee Priest, Shawn Ray, Kevin Levrone, Dennis Wolf, Kai Greene, Victor Martinez and Flex Wheeler, plus other names along the way.

Walker, who beat Samson Dauda and Derek Lunsford to take the 2026 Mr. Olympia title, did not hesitate much. He started with Lee Priest over Shawn Ray, then moved to Dennis James and Branch Warren. Warren held against Lee Labrada, but Kevin Levrone eventually took over.

Kai Greene goes on a run

Dennis Wolf then beat Levrone and Paul Dillett before Kai Greene entered. Greene beat Wolf, then won a head-to-head with Victor Martinez, advancing past Chris Cormier and Milos Sarcev.

The Greene-Martinez matchup was the most interesting for longtime fans. Both men starred in the original Generation Iron documentary. Martinez won the 2007 Arnold Classic and was runner-up to Jay Cutler at the 2007 Mr. Olympia. Greene finished second to Phil Heath at three straight Olympias from 2012 through 2014. Walker picked Greene, and our Kai Greene profile covers his career in depth.

Flex Wheeler ends the streak

Greene's run ended in the final matchup. Walker chose Flex Wheeler as his overall winner. Wheeler is widely regarded as one of the greatest never to win the Mr. Olympia. He is known for symmetry, proportions and muscle development, won four Arnold Classic titles and finished runner-up at the Olympia three times. Read more in our Flex Wheeler profile.

Walker's pick highlights a classic question: is the greatest physique the biggest one, or the most complete one?

Why it matters

Walker's own path gives this weight. He slipped to sixth at the 2025 Olympia, drew real doubt, and then came back with the conditioning to win in 2026, according to FitnessVolt. He also won the Arnold Classic in 2021, and he is now preparing for the 2027 Arnold Classic in Columbus. See our Nick Walker profile and the Arnold Classic 2027 preview for what is ahead.

A champion's preferences don't settle an argument fans have had for decades, but they show how a modern Olympia winner values symmetry and proportion alongside size. For the full history of the title, visit our Mr. Olympia page.

The takeaways

  • Walker's final pick in the challenge was Flex Wheeler.
  • Kai Greene beat Dennis Wolf, Victor Martinez, Chris Cormier and Milos Sarcev before losing to Wheeler.
  • Walker is the reigning Mr. Olympia and is preparing for the 2027 Arnold Classic.

Quick answers

Who did Nick Walker pick as the best bodybuilder never to win the Mr. Olympia?

In an Instagram winner-stays-on challenge, Walker chose Flex Wheeler as his ultimate winner.

Did Nick Walker choose Kai Greene or Victor Martinez?

He chose Kai Greene over Victor Martinez, and Greene went on to beat Chris Cormier and Milos Sarcev before losing to Wheeler.

How many times did Flex Wheeler finish runner-up at the Olympia?

Generation Iron reports that Wheeler finished runner-up at the Mr. Olympia three times and won four Arnold Classic titles.

Sources

Weigh in

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *